Election Judge Report, Apr 2021
Apr. 7th, 2021 09:16 pmI ended up being in charge of:
- The touchscreen voting machine (assembly and disassembly)
- The optical ballot scanner (assembly and disassembly and debugging)
- Wiring everything together
- Answering the phone (~50%)
- Tech support
- All things that involved lifting
- Getting paperwork ready to go
- Dealing with the election division + site rep
- Trying (and failing) to delegate work
- New judge mentoring
- A whole lot of the practical cleanup work
This was a lot, and it also didn't _look_ much like work to the voters. This is a stressful combination! I spent a lot of the time minute-by-minute doing laps around the school or reading, but I was fairly stressed for most of it, and about half the time when I came back from one of these laps there was a fire to put out.
Most of the real-actual-emergency fires involved the optical ballot scanner, which was flaky and required multiple calls to tech support to work out. Three times we had to have voters put their ballots in the emergency ballot slot for a while, to be loaded into the ballot box properly only when we had fixed the equipment. We ended up replacing it entirely, which I was mildly surprised actually worked.
For the rest of it, I did my best to just try to let it go when weird decisions were being made. One judge _really_ didn't want me to change how she'd organized the paperwork, even though she wasn't in charge of it and I was laying things out to speed up our eventual cleanup. When the other judges got it in their heads to start tearing down signs from the wall 1.5 hours before the polls closed, I pushed back for a bit, then I just got out of the way. Nobody wanted to switch jobs, and it wasn't my problem to fix, so I let it go. We had one straight-up yelling match when a voter came in and said they hadn't brought their main-in ballot with them, and every judge offered a different position. It was taxing.
But, of course, the day eventually ended. We even had an exciting change this time: a court order came in at the last minute mandating that we should _not_ share the election results with poll-watchers or on the windows of the facility (which is normally standard practice), which could shave up to 30-40 minutes off of our tear-down time (honestly, tear-down is mostly bound by how slow the dot matrix printer is in the optical scanner). But then the last voter simply wouldn't leave. He sat there staring at his ballot for about half an hour! We cleaned up everything around him, me sweating profusely by the end of it, and he didn't notice. Eventually one of the other judges said "sir, you can't look at your phone here", and he suddenly looked up, then finished his ballot in a couple of minutes. He dropped it in the ballot box, and we could finish tear-down over the next ~30 minutes (should have been less, but that's where the inability to work ahead on paperwork got us...)
My big lesson of the day is that I am eligible to be a Field Rep instead of an Election Judge proper, and I may well do that. This would basically be a roving tech support judge, checking in on a bunch of different polling places, keeping track of voter counts, and just generally _helping_ rather than running the place or being run. I think it'd suit me.
Election Judge Report - final
Nov. 6th, 2020 10:01 amI've posted plenty about the election judging process: set up at 5am, open at 6am, close at 7pm, get out by 8pm-ish. That 15 hour day is bad enough when you *aren't* bone-tired from the preceding election season, but this time I was already weakened. I barely slept the night before, and my son woke up at 4am with me to whine about how I was keeping him up. And I knew perfectly well that the hours after the election were going to be a never-ending exercise in reloading election results.
I was assigned to a different polling place this time, and I wasn't in charge. The guy that was in charge was a Republican, but friendly and experienced and dedicated to the process, which is really all you can want; in total we had 8 judges, 2 R and 6 D. It was enough for the day. We were given plenty of PPE - plexiglass shields for the check-in judges to hide behind, gloves and masks for the public, a huge vat of hand sanitizer that came out way too quickly in hilarious ways. The polling place was nearby this time too, in the gym of my son's grade school - much closer and easier to deal with, though I'm pretty sure the floors did a number on me compared to the carpet of my old place.
The day itself actually went *really* well. We had beyond-record early voting in our county, ~52% between mail-ins and actual in-person early voting, so the turnout on election day was much smaller than it would have been - about 450 people. Only two people used the touchscreen system all day, which is great because they're still terrible. The longest line we ever had was ~30 at opening, and that went quickly and with minimal kvetching. The weather was great, too, so we were able to keep the doors open and have a good airflow.
The biggest change for me was the not-in-charge thing. In the past, I had the phone with a direct line back to the election division, and I was in charge of all organization decisions and the like; this time somebody else was doing it, and our philosophies didn't quite match. It wasn't a *huge* problem, but we made different compromises to keep things flowing. I was in charge of most of the setup/tear-down of the ballot boxes and the touchscreen, which job is supposed to be shared.
And between it all, I managed to knock myself out for days with my work. I wasn't sitting as much; and because I wasn't in charge officially, I spent more time out and about with the voters, making sure they were going to the right places and were taken care of, rather than on the phone with the election division or something. I was up and down *a lot*, and by 2pm I was hurting, with hours to go. I pushed through, and hurt myself in the process. Now, several days later, I'm still aching and exhausted.
I'm still worried about the Covid stuff, a few days later. We're having a massive spike in Covid cases here in my county *right now*, and even though mask use was very good and I was keeping myself as safe as possible, I was still exposed to many hundreds of people. I'm intending to get a Covid test shortly. But I'm still hopeful about it; mask use really was universal, and nobody argued with us about it except for one judge that really wanted her lunch out in the public area for some reason. *sigh*
Once it was all done, I limped home and just stared off into space. Like, for hours. I made it to actual sleep by about midnight, not looking at the results but hearing some stuff from my wife, and woke up again at 3am to continue staring. I *hurt*, physically and emotionally and spiritually, and couldn't do anything about it. What dreams I had were full of shame and doubt and convoluted ties between politics and my home life. It was awful. When I weighed myself in the morning, I had lost 5 pounds, presumably all water.
And of course I'm still worried about the results. Locally, things mostly went well; the Democrats won a majority of our County Board and several State and County-wide seats, we've kept at least 2/3 of our Congresscritters (and while #3 is heartbreaking - Lauren Underwood is amazing! - she's not out yet, there's still some more ballots to count and the margin is not necessarily insurmountable), and of course we voted for Biden over Trump at every level I was connected to. The attempt to institute a progressive income tax in Illinois went down based on a vigorous campaign of lies and misdirections from the state's billionaires, so we're going to see a general tax hike and reduction in services instead, which sucks but was obvious from a mile away. Basically, our local Township Democrats did a *great* job.
I've managed to avoid looking at the national results in detail every 5 minutes, somehow.
I haven't started on it yet, but I do intend to start bugging our newly-elected officials to change the laws so that we can do 8-hour election judge shifts instead of full-day. This current system has its benefits, but it's too exhausting, and we're not getting as many judges as we could because people can't work like this.
But, at any rate, I survived. I've started trying to return to the world a bit, and I'm moving and working. The fight continues, especially with the next municipal elections starting up Right Now (petitions are due in just a couple of weeks).
Election Judge Report
Nov. 2nd, 2020 01:55 pmElection Judge Report: I've pretty much gathered what I'm bringing to the polls. I've got a pile of masks, and intend to at least trim my beard down tomorrow in case the N95 looks vital. I've got a face shield as well. Most of my "emergency" stuff (like spare clothes) can stay at home because Rebecca will be there and can bring me stuff if there really is a problem.
The county has had 50% voter turnout so far, out of ~640k registered voters in the county. That'll inch up when today's numbers are added, and tomorrow will be some more. I don't really know how busy this polling places is, but if it's similar to my last polling place, then we almost certainly should see <1000 people over the day, probably far fewer. But I don't know the facilities well, and so I'm still worried.
I'm not horribly concerned about voter intimidation here, but maybe that's a mistake. I know people that are on the 866-OUR-VOTE hotline, which helps, and I'm certainly willing to call for backup if it looks like it's necessary.
Tomorrow I'll be at the site at 5pm in person to set up and make things are okay. I'll have a little bit of time in between that and going to bed to get a few more things set up if necessary; I've already at least got breakfast pre-planned and the boy's lunches made for the next couple of days.
Here's hoping it all goes well.
Election Judge Report, 2020 Primaries
Mar. 18th, 2020 08:23 pmYesterday I worked as an Election Judge for the 2020 Primary Elections in DuPage County. This was my third turn as a judge, all of them at the same polling place in West Chicago.
This election was significantly different than my previous rounds simply because it happened during the Covid-19 pandemic. We're a few days into the push for "social distancing", where essentially everybody is strongly encouraged/required to stay home and not go out in public. This is not very conducive to running a proper election; not only is the electorate much less willing to go out and vote, but the Judges that run the whole thing are generally the people most vulnerable to the disease. We might technically have postponed the election, at the cost of doing some damage to our democracy as a whole (and will there be a better time any time soon?), but the state chose to go forward. And so, even though I was particularly comfortable with it, I went forward and did my job.
The mess started for me the night before. I got a call from one of my judges, begging me in so many words to tell him that it was okay to not make it because he had no insurance and had pre-existing conditions that put him at significant risk. I wasn't enough of a good manager to tell him to stay home, but I told him that it was up to him to make the decision for him and his family; that's all I felt I could do. Another student called off at the last minute, and another worker texted off. It wasn't great, but I still ended up having a total of seven judges - three long-term veterans, three students, and myself. It was enough, but it was a little bit tight.
We got as much cleaning equipment as the Election Division was able to get a hold of at the last minute, and honestly they did a pretty good job. It was delivered by the Department of Transportation first thing in the morning, indicating that they had successfully coordinated a multi-department field operation in just a few days - not bad! They had mixed the hand sanitizer and the cleaning fluid on their own, and put them in dollar-store squirt bottles and IKEA soap dispensers. It absolutely felt like the best that could be done with limited time and stretched supply lines. We did not get enough rubber gloves, and I strongly suspect that they scrambled to get the ones we did get. We had enough the night before to have one pair per judge, and that was it. I managed to find a few gloves around the house for myself, and so did most of the other judges. But that's what we had. We had to improvise on how to lay out the voting booths, because the plan had been written before the six-foot-distance guideline had been set; we at least managed to get ~4-5 feet between the booths.
We had two new technologies this time, because the previous technologies had aged out and the County Board had been forced to give the Clerk the money to buy replacements. The first was simply a new cell phone; the old ones simply didn't function anymore, and the new ones were solid USB-C flip phones, nothing to write home about but amusing. Second were the PollPads: iPads with appropriate software for running a polling place. The software was slick and fairly effective, with the significant change being that the voters signed directly on the iPad instead of on a sticker. It reduced paper usage, it let us eliminate another old piece of tech (the thing that printed up the voter cards for use with the touchscreen), and it really did speed things up. The major difficulty is that the signatures on the iPads were, well, signatures on iPads - not as high res as paper and more difficult to do signature comparisons.
We spent a lot of the day wiping down the booths and the shared equipment (booths, pens, styluses). It wasn't great that we were all touching the same iPads over and over again - this was the possible disease vector, and we didn't really have better solution. We also didn't really have enough manpower to keep everything stationed and cleaned, so we only hooked up 3/4 PollPads and had to keep our breaks short. The rest of the building was more "off-limits" than usual, with the school outright closed and even non-essential staff limited. I saw two teachers, two custodians, and a few cleaners.
The election day was never particularly slow. We had 422 voters over the day; it was never empty for more than a few minutes at a time, and we never had a line of more than ~3 people queued up at our three check-in stations. Only once did anybody have to wait for a voting booth, and then for only a few minutes.
There were only a few really-cranky voters. Some of these were of the "how dare you make me take a partisan ballot!!11!" style, where they were upset to be participating in a partisan primary. The others were upset about their voter registration having issues, which was a bit of a problem, but we were able to work it out consistently. We never had to turn anybody away except because a) they were in the wrong polling place or b) they came late.
We did have two, err, interesting cases where a voter came and found that they had already voted. In both cases we had the same problem: the voter's spouse had voted for them accidentally. The address matched, the name close-enough-to-matched (and in one case the recorded name was just initials), the signatures at least partially matched on the iPad, and the voter didn't notice the confusion when they signed. So, yeah. Not good. In both cases both voters did get to vote and it all worked out okay, but tech support was quite helpful to make sure it happened.
At the end of the day, we managed to get out of there in about an hour. The Clerk had changed the responsibilities around a bit, so that the work was a bit better divvied up; I think that this worked pretty well. The biggest time cost was for the ballot scanner machine to print off four copies of the results; that thing is a tank, but it's slow, and it had to be done serially and only after the last voter had dropped in his ballot. But we got everything packed up, I drove over with another judge to the courthouse, dropped everything off, and got the other judge back to the polling place and his car so he could go home. I was back by 8:45 or so, just, err, around 16 hours after I left.
So. Good day. I'm still tired.
(no subject)
Feb. 12th, 2020 12:01 pmVarious Reviews
Feb. 3rd, 2020 02:17 pmBloodstained: Ritual of the Night: this is pretty much Castlevania: Symphony of the Night with the serial numbers filed off and some small-but-annoying amounts of jiggle physics. It's the first Metroidvania game I've played all the way through for years now, and that pretty much because it's available for Switch, which is a good system upon which to play a Metroidvania. Your character (I'm sure she had a name) runs through a castle exploring and killing demons, stealing their powers to make herself more powerful. Sometimes there are bosses, more of the time you're lost and just wandering around. There's a plot in there, I'm sure, but I ignored it (and I think that was a good call). I got caught up in the 100%-ing the game for a while, and I'm not sure yet if I'll fully succumb.
Okay, various == 2.
Best Picture
Jan. 28th, 2020 11:11 amI've seen 7.5 out of the 9 Best Picture nominees this year. Some thoughts.
1917
It's a World War 1 movie, and it's good at its job. I don't really know what more to say than that; it portrays the horrors and banality of war in a shocking manner, and the central "one shot" gimmick is only a little bit in the way.
Ford v Ferrari
This movie was perfectly good, and I see why others found it appealing. It's a movie about cars and racing and bonds between men and corporate culture; at its core it's a sports movie, so not quite my thing but I do appreciate what it is.
The Irishman
Scorsese does another mob movie, this time about Jimmy Hoffa with a side dose of meditation on age. It probably needed to be split into at least two parts in order to really work; parts of it were classic Scorsese, parts of it were simply slow and meditative, and they don't really work together that well.
Joker (didn't see)
I really don't want to see this movie. I hate the Joker as a character so much, regardless of this movie; ever since he combined "chaotic evil" with "perfect omniscience", sometime around _Dark Knight_ and well after Mark Hamill's take on him, I've been angry at the very concept of him. He works in relation to Harley Quinn, and he *doesn't* work in relation to Batman. So I don't want to watch an origin story about him, thank you very much.
Jojo Rabbit
The trailers made it out to be a wacky story about Hitler and a 10yo kid, and that wasn't right. Instead it's a WW2 movie about Germany and hatred and survival and futility and all of the standard stuff, just focusing on the perspective of a child. It was sad and painful and strong. I really liked it a lot.
Little Women
I had never seen an adaptation of Little Women before this one, so I really didn't know what to expect, nor did I know for sure where the lines were between "what I should expect" and "what Gerwig added to the mix". Everything about the movie was excellent - actors, script, directing, sets, costumes, and the interpretation of the material. It's probably my pick for second best.
Marriage Story (half-watched, may not complete)
I watched about half of this last night, and stopped. It's a movie about a painful divorce between theatre types involving lots of money and multiple cities and a kid; so there's parts of it that are "but for the grace of the Gods go I", and there's parts that are simply out of my world. It was painful and ugly and made me feel about how I expect that people that don't like blood feel about action movies.
Once Upon A Time... In Hollywood
I feel like this movie fits Tarantino fans perfectly. It mostly baffled me, but I didn't really know much about the time period it was supposed to be covering, and didn't come out really caring.
Parasite
This is the best picture. This should win. This was a truly excellent and thoughtful movie about class and duty and a variety of other things that I still don't feel comfortable talking about because the spoilers are still worth avoiding.
I still have one of these?
Dec. 30th, 2019 10:00 pmToday I talked with a newer friend, and we talked about what we'd do if we only had a little while to live. My first response: write what I could to everyone that needed it. She was shocked, mostly because she hasn't seen me write that much.
That's two kicks to the head in ~24 hours. I should pay attention to that.
The AV Club died today
Aug. 23rd, 2017 09:52 pmI've been reading The AV Club in some form or another for, what, twenty-some years now? It started out as zine-style media reviews in the back of issues of The Onion; they were fine, and I read them casually and learned about stuff I'd want to read or watch or listen to. And when everything went to the Internet they adapted, hiring a bunch of really good reviewers and (eventually) focusing heavily on TV reviews. They've been the best in the business for years, even as the site has shriveled.
They threw it all away today. It turns out that the site had been bought by the Gawker guys a while ago, and Gawker got bought by Univision. So today they converted to the "official" standard software for the corporation - Kinja - and made the site unusable. The navigation is borked beyond repair, the RSS feeds are broken, old articles are at best discoverable with a search engine, the new design is white-space awful, and (worst of all) the comment section, which was a gem in the same way that Usenet was once a gem, has been blown away and replaced with something much less usable, harder to navigate, and hostile to both commenter and lurker.
I was expecting it to be bad. This is far worse than I expected. And I'm seriously wondering how I'm supposed to find out which new television shows or movies I want to watch now, let alone figure out where to read discussions of the latest episode of the shows I already watch.
Can we please stop undervaluing community? Gaah.
I adopted Jesse Custer Skirvin and his sister Tulip O'Hare on 20 Jun 2005. He chose me when I visited the shelter, ignoring the attacks of his fellow cats in order to sit on my lap in the communal room; this was new to me, and utterly compelling. When I brought them home and let the pair out of their carriers, he and Tulip explored the house together until they found my recliner; they then jumped in and started cleaning each other immediately. And that set the stage for the next eleven years.
Jesse was a black long-haired house cat, average size and weight, with a kinked tail, a loud and easily-provoked purr, and a chirpy little voice that he used regularly. He was even-tempered, and loved people - he would generally end up on the lap of every visitor to the house, and was known to climb on the shoulders of our house cleaners. He liked staring at the outside, but had no interest in escaping; that's not where the people were! He was not horribly adventurous or warlike but managed to remain Alpha for most of his life, and trusted me utterly and completely. He was omnipresent, following me everywhere and sitting next to me if my lap was for some reason unavailable; he would follow me to the kitchen or the bathroom, he would sit with me through a whole game of Civilization, he would talk to me in the shower, he would be at my feet when I went to sleep and still there when I woke in the morning. Jesse was by no means my first cat, but he was the first cat that was truly and completely mine, and I was his. We were kitty-human soul mates.
In return, I dedicated as much of my life to Jesse as I reasonably could. I left pedestals near any place that I might sit, so that he would be comfortably off the floor. I learned that I could call him and he would come, and so I did so regularly; he figured out his own cries that would call me. I was by far his favorite toy, and while he otherwise never hurt a human, he felt no compunctions towards scratching and biting me in mock battles. I gave him my attention, my time, and my love, and yet I only gave a fraction of what I was given.
The greatest time of Jesse's life was just when I left Champaign to live in Mountain View. I flew with him back to California a couple of weeks before my then-wife was able to join me with Tulip; and so for those couple of weeks it was just the two of us. He never left my lap or my side during that time; he purred and rubbed against me and, most interestingly, refused to fight with me for any reason; claws or teeth would have been an insult against Paradise. It was only a couple of weeks, but for the duration he was in Kitty Heaven, standing next to his master and nobody else. We both loved every minute of it.
I may not know for sure how old Jesse was when he died, but it was somewhere in the range of 16 or so - old, but not ancient. I know that he slowed down over the last couple of years, as old age and arthritis overtook him. But he never stopped loving me or trusting me, and even as Tulip took over as Alpha, he held firm to his control of my bed and my lap. He tolerated my son, for which I am eternally grateful. And even in his final days, he was always there when I went to sleep and when I woke up in the morning. And in return, Rebecca and I were there for him when he went to sleep as well.
Now, when I look around the house, I expect to see him nearby, or perhaps already on my lap like a ninja kitty. I listen to hear his "I'm lonely!" roar, or his "hmmph" of air let out as he jumped to the floor, or his whine asking for his (mostly-full) food dish to be refilled. In the evenings and mornings I expect to wake up to his sneezes, or the rustling of him climbing under the covers to lie next to me, or the feeling of claws lightly poking my beard, begging for attention. And when none of that comes, my heart breaks again. I want to give him my love, and he is not there to take it.
Jesse, it was an honor to take care of you for these years, and I will never forget you. You will not be my final cat, but you always be the one against which other cats will be judged. I will tell your story to those that ask, and your memory will not be forgotten. And when I see you again, in the place where no shadows fall, I promise you my lap and my love.
Ave atque vale, my beast.
Django Unchained
Jan. 5th, 2013 11:03 amDjango Unchained: 9 (out of 10)
While I should really try to avoid ranking this movie against the rest of Tarantino's filmography, I should at least compare it to its most obvious comparison: 2009's Inglorious Basterds. Both movies showed us that the oppressed people could fight back; but while Basterds reminded us to Never Forget, Django Unchained showed us pieces of history that we, as a culture, have already forgotten.
Django Unchained is a movie about slavery. Yes, it is billed as a revenge flick, and there certainly is a lot of revenge in the movie; but this revenge is against slavers and their minions. The elements of the revenge flick form a frame around which we can witness and be reviled by the racism, violence, and degradation inherent in the 1850s US South. And what comes out is brutal, disturbing, and still entertaining.
As this is a Quentin Tarantino film, many elements of the film are clearly set before entering the theatre. The direction will be stylized and top-notch; the dialogue will generally heavy and speech-y, interspersed with light and funny scenes and it will all be good; the quality of the actors will be excellent across the board, save perhaps for Tarantino's cameo role; and the violence will be integral to the film and over-the-top. All of these things are true, and I will not dwell on them.
What is worth dwelling on is the actors themselves. Jamie Foxx delivers an excellent and understated performance as the titular Django, a freed slave that works as bounty hunter to free his wife. Christoph Waltz is a German dentist/bounty hunter that frees Django, in a curious juxtaposition to his role in Tarantino's previous movie, Inglorious Basterds. Most impressively, Samuel L Jackson plays the aged head slave of the Candyland plantation; to his peers he is in charge, and to his masters he is quite simply a dog. The mix is fascinating. And these are only the lead roles!
Many of the set pieces are top notch, and spoiling them would do a disservice to those reading the review. The segment with the proto-KKK sticks out in my mind as very Blazing-Saddles-y; the dinner-time conversations were appropriately tense; Tarantino's character made me giggle; and the opening scene did an excellent job of showing us what the movie was going to be about. This is a movie that will survive multiple viewings, if just to see a few of these scenes over and over again.
One point worthy of note was the soundtrack, which is a mix of 60s- and 70s-style spaghetti western music with the occasional piece of gangsta rap where appropriate. Even when played over-loud it added to the film; but I still doubt I'm going to buy a copy of it any time soon.
At any rate, this was a top-notch, challenging, and stressful film. It is both a stark reminder of the history of racism in our country, and an excellent use of cathartic revenge. If you have the stomach for the blood and violence, you should see it.
Rating: 9 (out of 10)
URL: http://wiki.killfile.org//reviews/movies/django-unchained/
Lincoln: 8 (out of 10)
Lincoln tells the story of the passage of the 13th Amendment through the House of Representatives during the lame-duck Congress following President Lincoln's re-election in 1864. The Civil War is wrapping up, and Lincoln feels that he has to push through the amendment before the war ends, before the national political sentiment changes. And so he fights to consolidate his party, flip voters of the opposition to his side, and otherwise use all of his political capital to accomplish his goal: end slavery in the United States of America.
At its core, Lincoln is a movie about national politics. To be sure, this isn't really modern politics we're talking about; this is the politics of the 1860s, where the politicians have beards, wigs, and large hats; communication works by telegraph, travel by horse or riverboat; and of course the bloodiest American war is still raging. But none of this fundament!
ally chan
ges the core of Washington: politics are hard, politics can be incredibly dirty, and politics matter. (It also turns out that politics can make for fascinating viewing.)
But that's not really that all that Lincoln is about - indeed, it's in large part about Lincoln himself. He is shown as a sad man, with a painful and complicated family life and a deep need to accomplish what he thinks is right, even at the cost of doing things that he knows are wrong (or, at least, that he isn't convinced are right).
More than that, we see that Lincoln is a storyteller. Lincoln tells stories to illustrate his moral points; he tells stories to inspire those around him; and he tells stories to silence the yelling around him. He laughs at himself, he goes on tangents, and he inspires the more frustrated around him to stomp out. He controls the room with his quietly-told stories, dirty jokes, and inspirational speeches. And I came out of every o!
ne of the
m thinking "I would vote for this man." It was extremely effective, and one of the most fascinating parts of the movie.
Still, what I found most fascinating was the politics itself. The strong-arm politics, whipping for votes, the barely-concealed bribery and corruption, the speeches for the press, the careful selection of words, the powers and limitations of party politics, and the dangers of virtue - these were all presented as clearly as a season of the West Wing. The difference, of course, is that this is at least related to what actually happened, and the fight was one that mattered. That touches me much more effectively than a simple fire fight.
The casting and acting ware spectacular. Daniel Day-Lewis should win the Best Actor Oscar for this work; I wouldn't be surprised to see Tommy Lee Jones be nominated for Best Supporting Actor for his work as Thaddeus Stevens. It seemed that the entire Congress was made up of first- and se!
cond-rung
actors, and most of them had a chance to shine. I was perhaps unduly moved by S Epatha Merkerson's role (which I won't spoil).
As for Spielberg's role - well, besides the clear skill at dramatizing the politics (something that I would have been happy with, but most audiences perhaps less so!), his role seemed pleasantly muted, compared to his normal directorial work. This was a good thing; this was neither a war movie nor a rollicking/whimsical tale, and the story needed to be told differently. But it was still clearly Spielberg, and I was happy with his part.
There were flaws, certainly. I would have preferred that the movie ended a bit earlier. I'm not sure that dragging things out until Lincoln was actually shot and killed added anything that couldn't have been more effectively handled with a text box; and, indeed, more context could have been added at that point. I think that the relationship between Lincoln and his family could have either been b!
eefed up
a bit, or pulled down; either way, it didn't seem to be quite right. The soundtrack seemed a bit muted. And I'm still a bit disappointed that the movie didn't come out before the elections (even as I understand why it couldn't).
But all in all, this movie was excellent.
Rating: 8 (out of 10)
URL: http://wiki.killfile.org//reviews/movies/lincoln/
(no subject)
Sep. 10th, 2012 12:38 pmI read The Player of Games by Iain M. Banks the other day. I don't really want to review it overtly, but I do have one comment worthy of note: I did not enjoy the gaming, and I'm still not entirely sure why. Perhaps writing something down will help?
The game in question - Azad - was used in the book as a tool upon which an entire interstellar empire was based; the best player was set up as the Emperor, and other top players ended up with top government/military jobs. The game itself theoretically "modelled the society", and therefore had to be both near-infinitely complex and nevertheless understandable. There were gambling elements, cards, and group play elements; but fundamentally, it appeared to be modelled on Go, albeit significantly scaled up.
Somehow, this hurt my ability to suspend disbelief.
Much of the book also discussed the idea of game theory and societies that value high-level game players and theoreticians. The top gamers in (another) society write essentially peer-reviewed articles on the games they play. Well, okay, I'm fine with that - but part of this seems to indicate that the games that are considered "real" fit into a few categories. And those categories were quite narrow. Specifically, they were so narrow that they would eliminate virtually every game that I play today. And I think that there's something a bit strange about that.
A few mechanics that seemed to be left on the floor:
- Worker Placement
- Auctions (except in relation to gambling)
- Rock-paper-scissors (for units - they seemed to be one-size-fits-all)
- Any kind of economic system
- Simultaneous actions of any form (or maybe there were? I got a very strong sense of asynchronous actions
- Network building (this could have been abstracted away, I guess)
- Doing anything interesting with the cards, other than using them as a "battle card" system, including laying them as "mines". There wasn't much in the way of hand management, for instance.
- More abstractly, close back-and-forth interaction between the various "sub"-games.
Sure, several of these didn't exist at the time of writing. Still, given that effort was put into dismissing other styles of games, it just felt odd.
Maybe the real lesson here is that this felt weak because it pre-dated the recent board game "revolution". It focused on Go and war games because that's what the author was knowledgeable about, or could do research on. But I'm still a little bit irritated to see whole genres of game just ignored, including genres that did exist when the book was written (1988), including my current favorite, 18xx, which dates back to 1974 (or 1986 in my preferred incarnation).
Aah, well. I'm still going to read the next one.
Retiring from Usenet Moderation
Jun. 1st, 2012 10:30 amAccording to my CV, I currently moderate four newsgroups:
- humanities.philosophy.objectivism (since 1995)
- comp.std.announce (since 2006)
- rec.arts.comics.reviews (since 2005)
- news.admin.moderation (since 2007) (technical moderation only)
All of these groups depend on my main home system, vulture.killfile.org, to operate properly. And, as I think I've already mentioned here, that host went down while I was in Europe. Posts were lost and everything.
Upon reflection, I think I'm okay with that, especially in light of my shift to using flea.killfile.org for my mail for a while...
I think the time has probably come to step down from moderating these groups. I'll give it a little while, I suppose, but unless somebody convinces me otherwise, I'll probably shut all of the bots down at the end of the month.
(no subject)
May. 24th, 2012 03:05 pmI just got back from a combination dual-honeymoon/Dad-Retirement vacation with Rebecca, my parents, and my brother and his wife. I'm not sure what to say about it, at least in between "it was good"/"I am so tired" and a several section treatise.
The trip:
Flying
I want to make less 12-hour flights in my life.
Rome
We spent two days and nights in Rome, including one day and one night with a private tour guide seeing the city and major locations. There was no possible way to see enough, but we did go to the Colosseum, one of the catacombs, and St Peter's Basilica, and all were gorgeous. I could have spent a week here. I really need to get through these pictures!
Our tour guide was especially professional.
We also went to the Vatican Museum, with a separate tour guide. Rebecca could have used with less explanations; I found him useful.
Week-Long Cruise
The cruise was from Rome to Rome:
- Firenze
- Cannes (for the film festival, whee!)
- Marseille
- Barcelona
- (Day at Sea)
- Napoli/Pompeii
- Rome (and then home)
I could talk about each individual day in great detail if I felt like it, but I don't want to do so right now. Maybe later?
As for the ship: the Norwegian Epic is a monstrously ugly ship, with a capacity of ~4000 people. The ship experience was flawed, mostly because of the sheer scale of things; there were just too many people! The food was good as long as you paid extra for the specialty restaurants, or ate the Indian food at the buffet. The rooms were fine, but so much effort was spent on the balcony rooms that the place was just ugly from the outside. We got acts like the Blue Man Group and Cirque du Soleil instead of (just) standard ship fare, but the shows had technical problems. And I think I'd rather have gratuities not be included.
Returning Home
I wish that killfile.org hadn't died on Day 3. Grr. It's back now, but now I really have to re-double my efforts to move things to the cloud...
The cats were mad at us for only a few minutes.
Overall Thoughts
It really was great having a vacation with my family. It had been a long time, after all; and we do all get along, even the wives. Our great fear was that the Core Skirvin Clan would overwhelm Rebecca and Celeste, but it went pretty well, and nobody killed anybody else.
I'm not sure if this will the Final Honeymoon for Rebecca and myself.
I am happy, and so, so tired.